This website requires JavaScript for the full experience.
Skip to main content

Can Masculinity and Vulnerability Exist Side by Side?

We’ve teamed up with Whole Man Academy to get our members thinking about the big M, masculinity. Over a series of talks at The Collective Old Oak, we’ve discussed movies and manhood, the changing face of masculinity and how to be vulnerable in today’s society. We got chatting to Anthony Astbury, co-founder of the Whole Man Academy to find out more about why he set it up in the first place, and what we can all learn from talking openly. 

“For me, the quest for the perfect physique started when I was 21,” says Anthony. “I suffered a spontaneous pneumothorax (or collapsed lung) and lost a lot of weight over 6 months of inactivity. After that I wanted a body like a Men’s Health cover model, that’s as masculine as you can get right? I would go to the gym 5 days a week, eat a healthy diet, but still drink a lot. I now realise I linked my self-worth with my physique. If I hadn’t been to the gym for a few days, I felt rubbish.”

“I’m now 41 and more interested in how I feel and act, rather than how others see me. It’s impossible to control what they think, so no use worrying about it. I’m now just trying to do my best as a dad, partner, businessman and co-founder.”

In 2018, Anthony co-founded the Whole Man Academy alongside BBC News Editor and writer Matthew Shaw, as a space where men can get together to talk mindset, masculinity, mental strength, resilience, and male identity.

The alarming statistics show that there is a mental health crisis in the U.K, with men being adversely affected the most. They often grow up thinking that talking openly isn’t very ‘manly’. But the Whole Man Academy is challenging those stereotypes and changing the face of what being ‘a man’ is.

“At one of our events, we asked a mixture of backgrounds, ages, and sexualities to help us understand the concept of masculinity. For most men, it depends on the world he grew up in.” Anthony explains. “What were his parents' values? Did he live in a loving environment? Who were his role models as a boy? Was someone around for advice and support?”

“We now know that it’s ok to be vulnerable, it’s ok to say I could do with some help. Though we still have lots of work to do, to help men and women feel comfortable in their own skin.”

This got us to thinking, girls, boys and everyone in between, how vulnerable do we allow ourselves to be? With Anthony’s help we set ourselves a little homework, getting to grips with this vulnerability thing...

Grab a friend or family member and ask yourselves a few or all of these questions. Open up the conversation, dig deep and see what comes up. There are no wrong answers!

1. Do you allow yourself to be vulnerable? When things get challenging, do you keep it bottled up? 

2. What is your personal strategy to help you relax?

3. Can you listen to others and take their advice? Men don’t usually like taking advice from others but speaking to friends or professionals can really help.

4. What defines you as a person? Is it the job you have, the clothes you wear or your bank account balance? Should you let your circumstances define you?

5. Do you know when to take a break? From a behaviour, a certain environment, or social media for instance?

6. Does being sensitive mean, you can’t be strong? Does talking about your feelings and being honest, take strength?

7. What do you live for? What is your purpose?

8. What character traits do you want to be remembered for?